PRESS RELEASE

The Health Committee, which oversees the Department of Health in N Ireland, invited witnesses to give evidence regarding the draft Abortion Guidelines recently issued for consultation by the Department of Health.

After hearing evidence on the 17th October 2008 from various witnesses, including Mrs Johanna Higgins, Barrister of the Association of Catholic lawyers of Ireland, the Health Committee has produced its response and published the full minutes of the evidence given in Hansard.

The Health Committee states;

“The Committee fully endorsed the statement by Professor John Keown, Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Georgetown University who argued that 'The starting point of the Guidance should have been a clear statement of the illegality of abortion in Northern Ireland: that it is a crime punishable by a maximum of life imprisonment to use any means with intent to procure miscarriage, and an offence to supply means knowing that they are to be used with that intent. The Guidance should then have recalled the central if not sole purpose of this prohibition: the protection of the unborn child, a purpose which has informed the law against abortion for over 700 years. Only when the rule had been clearly stated should the scope of the exception have been considered'.”

This is welcomed by the ACLI, who presented Professor John Keown’s statement in their evidence to the committee.

Mrs Higgins says: “ We asked Dr Keown for his view on the guidelines given that he is a leading expert in the field of ethics and abortion law, we are delighted to see that the Health Committee have taken on board the serious concerns raised in relation to the legal failings of the present draft guidance”.

Mrs Higgins stated during her evidence to the Committee:

“The issue before the Department is to explain the criminal law on abortion. Abortion is a matter of justice and criminal law and it should not be regarded as a medical issue per se. In this case, it is a matter of justice for the unborn child that the law should be stated correctly. The criminal law on abortion exists entirely to protect the unborn child; that is its one purpose. However, the departmental guidelines do not include a single mention of the victim, which, in this area of law, is the unborn child. That is a gross omission, to say the least.” (Hansard)

The Department of Health invited evidence from both the pro life lobby and those who seek to liberalise abortion laws. The only legal and medical evidence given were from the Association of Catholic Lawyers of Ireland and Doctors for Life.


End

Notes to editor:

Evidence session before Health Committee:
http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/health/2007mandate/moe/2008/081017.htm

Report of the Health Committee and endorsement of Dr Keown’s statement:
 http://www.niassembly.gov.uk/health/2007mandate/responses/081110.htm

FULL STATEMENT BY DR KEOWN.

The opening statement of the Guidance on the Termination of Pregnancy ("Within the scope of this Guidance and the law in Northern Ireland, each Health & Social Services Trust must ensure that its patients have access to termination of pregnancy services”) is seriously misleading.
 
The starting point of the Guidance should be a clear statement of the illegality of abortion in Northern Ireland: that it is a crime punishable by a maximum of life imprisonment to use any means with intent to procure miscarriage. The Guidance should then recall the central if not sole purpose of this prohibition: the protection of the unborn child, a purpose which has informed the law against abortion for over 700 years. Only when the rule has been stated should the scope of the exception be considered. Similarly, the Guidance should clearly state the law against child destruction and its central purpose, the protection of a child capable of being born alive, and then note the exception to this prohibition. (It is remarkable that paragraph 2.6 of the Guidance, which purports to quote the statute, misstates this exception by omitting the important word 'only'.)
 
Would one begin Guidance on the law of theft, which recognizes that in exceptional circumstances A may lawfully appropriate B’s property, by saying that "within the scope of law of theft, the government should ensure that everyone has access to everyone else’s property"? Further, just because there may be a defence to abortion in exceptional circumstances does not mean that the government is under a duty to provide access to abortion in those circumstances, any more than it is under a duty to provide citizens ready access to weapons for use in self-defence. Moreover, the government has a discretion as to how to allocate its healthcare resources: it is perfectly entitled to deploy those resources on medical procedures which do not involve the destruction of life.
 
John Keown MA DPhil PhD
Rose F Kennedy Professor of Christian Ethics
Kennedy Institute of Ethics
Georgetown University


About Professor John Keown


John Keown is the Rose F Kennedy Professor of Christian Ethics at Georgetown University, Washington DC. He graduated in law from Cambridge in 1984 and obtained a DPhil from Oxford in 1986 for a thesis on the historical development of the law on abortion. After being called to the Bar of England and Wales (Middle Temple) in 1986 he was appointed to a lectureship in medical law at the University of Leicester. In 1993 he was appointed to a lectureship in the law and ethics of medicine at Cambridge, where he was a Fellow of Queens’ College and Churchill College. In 2003 he assumed the Rose F Kennedy Chair at Georgetown.

His many publications include three books, all published by Cambridge University Press: Abortion, Doctors and the Law (1988); Euthanasia Examined: Ethical, Clinical and Legal Perspectives (1995) and Euthanasia, Ethics and Public Policy: An Argument Against Legalisation (2002)


Association of Catholic Lawyers of Ireland
Co - Founders Mrs Johanna Higgins LLB, Inn of the Court of Northern Ireland, The Kings Inns, Dublin and the Inner Temple, London, Barrister.
Legal Adviser to the All Party Pro Life Group, Stormont

Mrs Geraldine Foley LLB, The Kings Inns, Dublin and the Inner Temple, London, Barrister.

http://catholiclawyersblog.wordpress.com/
catholiclawyers@hotmail.com

AMDG+  All the actions and work of the ACLI are consecrated to the Immaculate Heart Of Mary.
 

Posted December 16, 2008
Catholic Family News
MPO Box 743 * Niagara Falls, NY 14302
905-871-6292

CFN is published once a month (12 times per year)
Subscription: $28.00 a year.
Request sample copy

  Home  •  Audio Cassettes & CDs   • New DVD Offer • CFN • Subscribe on line